How Florida's Gun Show Loophole Really Works

Gun shows are a popular way for individuals to buy and sell firearms in Florida. However, a loophole in Florida's gun laws allows certain individuals to purchase firearms without a background check.  This is known as the "gun show loophole."

Although there have been attempts to close the loophole, it remains controversial and is being debated at the federal and state levels. It’s important for individuals to understand the implications of the gun show loophole and to be aware of any changes to gun laws.

Man holds handgun in gun shop

Florida’s Gun Violence And The Gun Show Loophole

Florida has a high rate of gun violence, with more than 3,000 deaths by firearm reported in 2019 alone. This includes homicides, suicides, and accidental shootings. Gun violence is a significant public health concern in Florida, and many advocates for stricter gun laws argue that the gun show loophole is contributing to this problem.

In 2018, a study by the advocacy group Everytown for Gun Safety found that Florida had the second-highest rate of gun violence in the country. The study also found that states with universal background check laws had lower rates of gun violence than states without such laws.

Understanding The Gun Show Loophole

Although some counties in Florida require gun show attendees to submit to background checks when purchasing weapons, the overarching legality allows for unchecked purchasing in much of the state. 

What Is The Gun Show Loophole?

The ''gun show loophole,'' as it’s commonly called, refers to a statutory exemption that allows unlicensed private sellers – persons who don’t hold Federal firearms licenses – to sell firearms. These individuals usually sell their personal firearms without federal or state background checks. 

This lack of regulation has sparked controversy over the circumvention of Florida Concealed Carry Laws 2023 and other laws aimed at controlling firearm possession to ensure public safety. According to law enforcement experts and advocates of stricter gun control measures, such facilitation helps make lethal weapons available to those who would otherwise fail a standard background check due to past criminal activity or mental health issues.

Impact On Gun Control Measures In Florida

This loophole undermines key Gun Safety Act 2018 provisions enacted after the Parkland shootings. In particular, it compromises the Extreme Risk Act, which is intended to prevent individuals who pose a danger to themselves or others from having access to firearms. The gun show loophole also makes it easier for individuals to acquire high-powered assault weapons that can cause mass casualties in shootings.

It also increases existing gaps in the National Instant Background Check System (NICS) databases, which can result in potential offenders going undetected due to gaps in regulatory mechanisms. This situation complicates enforcing stricter concealed carry laws in Florida in 2023 and creates an ongoing legislative disconnect regarding more stringent firearms regulations.

Arguments For And Against Closing The Loophole

While there are arguments for and against closing the loophole, it will be up to lawmakers to determine whether or not to close the gun show loophole and how best to address the issue of gun violence in our society.

Arguments For Closing The Gun Show Loophole

Closing the loophole at gun shows would require all sales at gun shows to be subject to background checks to ensure that individuals with criminal backgrounds or mental health issues cannot easily purchase firearms. This would help prevent guns from falling into the wrong hands and potentially reduce gun violence.

Proponents argue that closing the loophole would increase community safety by minimizing the possibility of individuals acquiring guns without proper background checks. Stricter regulations on gun sales may reduce the number of illegal firearms in circulation and make it more difficult for criminals to obtain guns.

Critics of the gun show loophole argue that it creates a regulatory loophole that allows people to bypass background checks, making it easy for potential criminals or those with dangerous intentions to obtain firearms. Closing this loophole would help ensure consistent enforcement of firearms acquisition laws and promote responsible gun ownership.

Against Closing The Loophole

Opponents argue that closing the loophole interferes with an individual's Second Amendment right to bear arms. They believe that law-abiding citizens should have unrestricted access to firearms and see any attempt to regulate or close the loophole as an unnecessary restriction on their constitutional rights.

Some opponents argue that closing the loophole on gun shows would place an undue burden on law-abiding citizens who want to buy or sell firearms privately. They contend that requiring additional background checks could lead to delays and administrative hurdles for law-abiding citizens who want to exercise their right to bear arms.

Critics also question whether closing the loophole would have a significant impact on reducing crime. They point out that criminals are likely to seek illegal methods of obtaining firearms regardless of whether private sales at gun shows are regulated. They argue that addressing the root causes of crime, such as poverty and mental health issues, would be more effective in reducing gun violence.

Efforts To Close The Gun Show Loophole

Progress has been made in current efforts to close the loophole for gun shows in Florida, with a bill passed by a Senate committee despite objections from the National Rifle Association (NRA).

The 2020 Gun Violence Prevention And Community Safety Act

In January 2020, a Republican-led Senate committee in Florida passed a bill to close the gun show loophole. Despite strong objections from the National Rifle Association, the bill passed to improve public safety.

However, it didn’t require background checks for all person-to-person transactions, estimated to account for 20% of all gun sales. Instead, the seller would have to check the buyer's ID and fill out a form recording the transaction. Failure to complete these forms would result in a second-degree misdemeanor punishable by up to 60 days in jail.

As of March 2021, Florida has not yet closed the unlicensed sales loophole, which allows prohibited buyers to bypass a background check by going to an unlicensed seller at a gun show or online.

Opposition From The National Rifle Association

The NRA has been a prominent opponent of closing the Florida gun show loophole. Despite the recent legislation passed by the Florida Senate committee, the NRA has sharply criticized these measures as "nothing less than gun control." The NRA has proposed alternative solutions that would weaken existing gun laws at the federal level.

Their opposition highlights how contentious this issue is and underscores the divide between proponents of stricter gun control measures and those who oppose any restrictions on gun sales.

Florida has specific laws regarding gun ownership and use, and as a responsible gun owner, it’s important to understand your rights and obligations under the law. Our attorneys have extensive experience defending clients against gun-related charges and have successfully represented clients in numerous cases.

If you're facing gun charges in Florida, the Weinstein Legal Team is here to help. Give us a call today at (954) 845-0505 to schedule a consultation with one of our attorneys. We’ll review your case, answer any questions, and provide you with the guidance and support you need.


Call A Lawyer Start A Chat