What Happens When A Personal Injury Claim Goes Go To Court?

Many personal injury claims are resolved before a lawsuit is filed. However, if an adequate settlement cannot be reached outside of court, your attorney will file a lawsuit in court. A judge will usually set a deadline for phases within the lawsuit process. The entire process can take anywhere from months to several years, depending on factors such as the intricacy of the case.

The following details the process and phases you can expect if your personal injury case is taken to court.

What Happens When A Personal Injury Claim Goes Go To Court?

The Pretrial Phase

Before your trial starts, there are a few things that will need to be taken care of first. They include the following:

Complaint and answer phase – The Complaint is the document that details your allegations with regard to how you were injured and the extent of your damages. Usually, it's filed in the county where your injury occurred or where the party that damaged you resides.

Once filed, the Complaint is delivered to the defendant. The defendant must answer the Complaint in a set period of time. The Answer refers to the document in which the defendant admits to or denies the allegations of the Complaint.

Discovery phase – The discovery phase is the formal process of exchanging information between both parties regarding the witnesses and evidence that will be presented at trial. The main purpose of this phase is to narrow the issues and make the parties aware of the evidence that may be presented at trial.

Motions phase – A motion is a proposal written to the court requesting an asked-for order, ruling, or direction. There are a variety of different motions, and it has become standard practice to file certain kinds of motions based on the type of case. Sometimes a hearing is held so that the court can consider both sides of the argument.

Going to Mediation

Mediation is a method for alternative dispute resolution that can be requested at any point throughout the court proceedings. If requested, both parties, their attorneys, and a neutral mediator will be present throughout every session.

Both sides will present your case and engage in settlement negotiations if you attend mediation. These will be facilitated by the mediator, with both parties as well as their attorneys receiving the opportunity to contribute. Mediations are non-binding; either party reserves the right to accept or reject the offer.

Conversely, both parties can head to arbitration as an alternative dispute resolution. Sometimes, a court may require that a case goes to arbitration as opposed to the actual court because a judge may believe that a reasonable settlement is in reach. Other times, arbitration is a voluntary decision of both parties to save both the expense of court costs.

In arbitration, a hearing will take place between the plaintiff and defendant, judged by a neutral party known as an arbitrator. The difference between arbitration and mediation is simple. While mediations are non-binding, meaning either party can accept or reject the offer, arbitration is usually binding. When the arbitrator makes a decision about the settlement, it is final.

Going to Trial

A trial provides the plaintiff the opportunity to argue his or her case so that a jury can examine the evidence, decide what happened, and rule on whether to find the defendant liable or responsible for the plaintiff's injuries.

  • Jury selection
  • Opening statements
  • Witness testimony and cross-examination
  • Closing arguments
  • Jury instruction
  • Jury deliberation and verdict


Even if you receive a verdict in your favor, your personal injury case may not be over. Be prepared to deal with the possibility that the defense may appeal the case in search of a different verdict. If an appeal is not brought, there most likely will be a length of time before you receive your monetary compensation. Once you have received the check for all monies owed to you, you can consider your lawsuit complete.

How Many Personal Injury Claims Go to Court?

If going to court is a large concern of yours, you might not need to worry as much as you think. In fact, only four to five percent of the personal injury cases in the United States go to trial. Typically, 95 percent to 96 percent of personal injury cases are actually settled pretrial, according to the U.S. Department of Justice. One of the more recent editions of the Bureau of Justice Statistics Bulletin, Federal Tort Trials and Verdicts, states that in 2002-03, only 2% of tort cases (which include personal injury) went to a bench or jury trial.

There are many reasons why a majority of personal injury claims settle before heading to court. The fact that insurance companies are involved in most cases goes a long way in explaining the high rate of settlements. Generally speaking, insurers have the money to pay out claims and are less likely to take the risk of having no control over costs when they have to go to trial, deal with a jury, and pay legal fees.

Aside from the interests of insurance companies, there are situations in which settling can benefit both the defendant and the plaintiff.

  • Control Risks - If a defendant knows he is in the wrong and will be held responsible, he might not want to risk having the case be tried in front of a sympathetic jury, which could award a substantial settlement for pain and suffering or punitive damages. A settlement gives the individual more control over how much money is offered.
  • Stay Out of the Public Eye - In the situation that the case involves a larger company or individual with a public profile, a settlement allows the defendant to remain out of the public eye. Settlements can be drafted with the inclusion of a confidentiality agreement so that the case can remain under wraps.
  • Swifter Settlement - Trials can extend for months, or even years, in the case of appeals. If a victim is suffering from lost wages and medical expenses, waiting that long to receive financial relief may not be a feasible option.
  • Guaranteed Victory - When a case goes to court, there is no guarantee that a plaintiff will win the case. To avoid losing the case and receiving nothing in terms of compensation, settling can seem to be a safer option.

A personal injury attorney understands that the decision to settle or go to court can be incredibly complicated. That's why the compassionate attorneys at Weinstein Legal will walk you through the process from start to finish so you understand your odds of winning a case and what a potential trial could mean for your legal process.

How Long Does A Personal Injury Claim Take To Go To Court?

Not all personal injury cases will go to court. In some situations, the case may be settled in mediation or a settlement. Typically, if your case is going all the way to court, the trial will start anywhere from six to twelve months from the time of your injury. This timeframe will depend on how bad your injuries are, how much time is needed for case evaluation, discovery, and any attempts at mediation before going to trial.

Will My Claim Go to Personal Injury Claim Go To Trial?

Disputes over fault for an accident or injury are likely resolved through informal settlements. However, four to five percent of personal injury claims will become formal personal injury lawsuits. If your concern is whether or not your claim will go to trial, it's best to look at the common reasons why a case would head to court.

  • Both parties cannot agree on who caused the accident. If the plaintiff and the defendant cannot agree on who was responsible for the accident, there are few options but to go all the way to trial.
  • Both parties cannot agree on the compensation amount. Whether the insurance adjuster is unable or unwilling to negotiate, the other party is being unreasonable, or the victim feels they deserve an amount beyond the offered settlement when both parties cannot agree on compensation, the case will head to trial.
  • The plaintiff chose to sue. In some cases, the victim believes that to receive fair compensation and receive justice for the accident, the courtroom is the best place to hash things out.

Types of Cases That Go All the Way to Trial

Generally speaking, a case heads to trial when the two parties cannot agree. However, certain cases have more of a tendency than others to make it to trial. This is typical because the settlement amount is a large sum, or because the matter of negligence is being disputed.

Types of Injury Cases That Are Settled Outside of Court

The U.S. Department of Justice reports that nearly 96 percent of cases are settled outside of court. Examples of the types of cases that typically do not head to court include:

  • Property damage cases
  • 'Fender bender' accidents
  • Dog bites and animal attacks

What Should I Expect from An Experienced Injury Attorney?

Preparing for a court case typically begins long before a lawsuit is filed. If you've recently suffered injuries due to another's negligence, your first step should be to contact a trusted personal injury attorney, like the team at Weinstein Legal.

For all cases, trial preparation begins as soon as both the attorney and the client sign the attorney contract. A qualified personal injury attorney would begin gathering evidence and forming a solid case right away, ensuring that a victim has the best chance of securing compensation either through settlement or through a jury verdict.

Say, for example, if a plaintiff received severe whiplash after an accident with a negligent driver. The first step would likely be to negotiate with the at-fault driver's insurance company to come to a settlement. An experienced whiplash attorney would thoroughly investigate the facts of the case to secure the whiplash victim the maximum compensation for their injuries. If both parties fail to come to a settlement agreement, an attorney can file a formal lawsuit against the at-fault party on behalf of the victim.

What Should I Expect from My Personal Injury Trial?

Following the jury selection process, an attorney would begin by making his or her opening statements. This would consist of explaining how the defendant was responsible for the accident which caused the plaintiff's whiplash, and how the trauma to the neck has caused the plaintiff pain and suffering, lost time at work, and perhaps even permanent damage.

An attorney's opening statement would be followed by testimony from a medical expert witness, who would examine the material facts of the case, such as medical records. During cross-examination, the defendant may attempt to disprove the facts of the case. For example, the defendant's attorney can claim that the plaintiff's injuries are the result of a pre-existing injury and not the accident caused by the at-fault driver.

In this case, the plaintiff's attorney could call an accident reconstruction expert to the stand, to testify as to why the present accident resulted in the current whiplash injury. Witness statements would be followed by closing statements from the attorneys of both parties. Once all is said and done, the jury would be instructed to review the whiplash case's facts and be tasked with coming to a factual conclusion. After the jury deliberates, a verdict would be read.

Contact an Experienced Personal Injury Lawyer Today

If you have been injured in an accident and are considering filing a personal injury lawsuit to receive payment for the damages caused to you, you must have an experienced personal injury attorney on your side. Remember, you only have one opportunity to fight for the compensation you deserve. To schedule a free consultation, contact the Weinstein Legal Team today.

Call A Lawyer Start A Chat